How an ‘ad hoc’ hospitalist model evolved during India’s COVID surge
A year after the start of the COVID-19 pandemic, as the United States was getting a reprieve in new cases from its winter surge, the opposite was happening in the rest of the world. In India, a deadly second wave hit, crippling the health care system in the country for months.
Yugandhar Bhatt, MBBS, MD, a consultant pulmonologist with Yashoda Hospital–Malakpet in Hyderabad, India, told this news organization that someone looking at his hospital before the pandemic – a 400-bed multispecialty care unit – would see patients being treated for respiratory failure secondary to exacerbation of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, bronchial asthma, community-acquired pneumonia, and heart failure. About 30-40 patients per day were treated on an outpatient basis, and more than 30 people were admitted as inpatients.
“After [the] COVID-19 surge, our hospital totally divided into COVID and non-COVID [wards], in which COVID patients occupied 70% of [the] total,” he said. About half of COVID-19 patients were in the ICU, with half of those patients requiring supplemental oxygen.
During the first wave in India, which lasted from May to December 2020, 50% of patients who were intubated were discharged. The percentage of extubated patients decreased to 20% in the second wave, Dr. Bhatt said.
The death toll during the second wave of COVID-19 cases was unlike anything India has seen previously. Between March 1 and June 29, 2021, an estimated 19.24 million individuals were newly infected with COVID-19 and 241,206 patients died, according to Our World in Data, a project of the Global Change Data Lab. When the second wave peaked on May 22, more than 4,000 people were dying each day.
“All hospitals [in India] were treating COVID-19 more than any other acute or chronic disease,” Ramesh Adhikari, MD, MS, SFHM, a hospitalist with Franciscan Health in Lafayette, Ind., said in an interview.
Challenges arose in treating COVID-19 in India that ran counter to how medicine was usually performed. Physicians were seeing more inpatient cases than usual – and more patients in general. The change, Dr. Adhikari said, forced health care providers to think outside the box.
An ‘on-the-fly’ hospitalist model
Patients in India access health care by visiting a hospital or primary health center and then are referred out to consultants – specialist doctors – if needed. While India has universal health coverage, it is a multi-payer system that includes approximately 37% of the population covered under the government plan, a large number of private health care facilities and no caps on cost-sharing for the patient. Initiatives like Rashtriya Swasthya Bima Yojana in 2008 and Ayushman Bharat-Pradhan Mantri Jan Arogya Yojana in 2018 have attempted to close the gap and raise the number of lower-income individuals in India covered under the government plan and reduce out-of-pocket spending. Out-of-pocket payments still consist of about 70% of total health expenditures, according to the Commonwealth Fund.
Dr. Shyam Odeti
“There is not much scope for a hospitalist because it’s so cash driven,” Shyam Odeti, MD, SFHM, section chief, hospital medicine, at the Carilion Clinic in Roanoke, Va., said in an interview. “For a hospitalist, there is no urgency in getting them out of the hospital. There was no need for much efficiency before.”
The first issue during the second wave was figuring out which consultants would care for COVID-19 patients. As there is no dedicated specialty for infectious disease in India, the responsibilities fell to internists and critical care medicine consultants who volunteered. Both are considered small specialties in India. They became “makeshift hospitalists” who learned as they went and became the experts in COVID-19 care, treating their own patients while making themselves available for consultations, Dr. Odeti said.
While no official hospital medicine model in India exists like in the United States, the second COVID-19 surge caused these consultants to begin thinking like hospitalists. Tenets of hospital medicine – like team-based treatment across specialties – arose out of necessity during the crisis. “They were trying to implement a hospitalist model because that’s the only way they could treat COVID-19,” said Dr. Adhikari, an editorial advisory board member for the Hospitalist.
“Even in the U.S. when we started the hospitalist model, it started out of necessity. It’s a combination of creating efficiencies and improving quality,” Dr. Odeti said. “It’s the same thing in India. It’s borne of necessity, but it was [done] at a rapid pace.”
