Because of the barriers, metal detectors present an insurmountable financial obstacle for most hospitals. In addition, they present an issue with public perception. Many would argue that hospitals are (and should be) places of healing and sanctuary (e.g. “safe havens”), not places for suspicion and searches. In addition, although there is evidence that the use of metal detectors results in increased confiscation of weapons, there is no evidence that they result in fewer on-site assaults.5 Further complicating matters, almost a quarter of the shootings that occur in EDs result from the perpetrator grabbing a weapon from a security guard.3
Others advocate for stricter gun control laws and enforcement, an argument that has vehement advocates and critics on both sides and is unlikely to be resolved in the near future.
Take Action: Be Prepared
In the meantime, hospitalists are left with preparedness tactics that range from situational awareness to active shooter drills. Both are equally important and should be a part of disaster preparedness at any medical center regardless of size, type, or location. Hospitalists can and should take a lead in such preparedness. Current statistics show that hospitalists are employed in at least 85% of all U.S. hospitals. With such widespread penetration, hospitalists can have a huge impact on the preparedness efforts that can prevent such acts from occurring, as well as on organizational resilience and recovery if such an act does occur.
Such training is more important in healthcare settings than other workplaces, as medical personnel have to be specially trained to resist the temptation to help. For example, active shooter training instructs personnel to run, hide, or fight, none of which come “naturally” to those trained to save and rescue for a living. This training instructs anyone in the “Hot Zone” (where life is in direct danger) to run away from the scene (always preferred if feasible), hide (barricade the door, silence any devices, and stay still), or fight (use anything in sight to fight the shooter, and work as a team if feasible). These responses are the exact opposite of what most trained healthcare personnel are accustomed to doing in cases of emergency.
In Sum
The Michael Davidson story is very sobering by all accounts. Healthcare violence such as this, while rare, is devastating.
Hospitalists should lead the way in training and preparedness for violence prevention and mitigation, including active shooter simulation scenarios. We can all have a huge impact in reducing the risk of casualties should such an unpredictable event occur in our hospital.
Dr. Scheurer is a hospitalist and chief quality officer at the Medical University of South Carolina in Charleston. She is physician editor of The Hospitalist. Email her at [email protected].
References
- Freyer FJ, Kowalczyk L, Murphy SP. Surgeon slain, gunman found dead in day of crisis at Brigham. January 20, 2015. The Boston Globe online. Available at: http://www.bostonglobe.com/metro/2015/01/20/boston-police-investigate-report-shooting-brigham-and-women/Jhig9z8LO8A5PH9Er4vTiP/story.html?rss_id=Top-GNP&utm_source=Managed&utm_campaign=386d2ff709-Quality+%26+Patient+Safety+Update&utm_medium=email&utm_term=0_ebe1fa6178-386d2ff709-319388717. Accessed February 5, 2015.
- Barnet S. Gun violence in hospitals: how much of a threat is it really? January 21, 2015. Becker’s Hospital Review. Available at: http://www.beckershospitalreview.com/healthcare-blog/gun-violence-in-hospitals-how-much-of-a-threat-is-it-really.html. Accessed February 5, 2015.
- Kelen GD, Catlett CL, Kubit JG, Hsieh Y-H. Hospital-based shootings in the United States: 2000 to 2011. Annals of Emergency Medicine online. September 20, 2012. Available at: http://www.annemergmed.com/article/S0196-0644%2812%2901408-4/abstract. Accessed February 5, 2015.
- Calvert S, Scharper J, Roylance F. Experts: no need for metal detectors at Hopkins. September 17, 2010. The Baltimore Sun online. Available at: http://articles.baltimoresun.com/2010-09-17/business/bs-md-hopkins-hospital-security-20100916_1_metal-detectors-healthcare-security-and-safety-hospital-security-experts. Accessed February 5, 2015.
- Rankins RC, Hendey GW. Effect of a security system on violent incidents and hidden weapons in the emergency department. Ann Emerg Med. 1999;33(6):676-679.