The horses were seemingly easygoing and quick to please, easily following cues to change direction or course. The mules were more hesitant and seemed to need to understand why they were being asked to do something before they acquiesced to the demand.
And when we approached a narrow rocky downslope, the mules were slow, steady, and confident, whereas the horses were seemingly uncomfortable and less agile. And, indeed in researching mules, they seem to have gotten a very bad rap over time (as evidenced by the term “stubborn as a mule”).
Charles Darwin actually categorized mules as an example of “hybrid vigor,” which is a rare example of when an offspring is actually better in most ways than either of its parents. Compared to its parental species, mules have more intelligence, endurance, longevity, health, speed, height, and agility. Also to their advantage, they have harder skin and hooves, allowing them to weather and endure more treacherous conditions.
With all of this newfound knowledge of the mule, it struck me what remarkable similarity some physicians have with mules and the role that these mules are likely serving within our organizations. These physicians are probably labeled as stubborn, obstinate, resistant, or impatient. But maybe they are actually intelligent, agile, and appropriately cautious. Maybe the resistance they express in the organization is serving to warn others about the rotten wooden bridges.
HM Takeaway
Similar to a ranch, most hospitals probably function best with a healthy combination of horses and mules. So if you get an opportunity, next time you encounter physicians at your hospital acting like mules, you should congratulate them and appreciate their mule-like characteristics. Recognize the contribution these types of physicians are making, in their own way, to the greater good of the organization.
After all, we can’t—and shouldn’t—all be horses. TH
Reference
1. Hauer J. The Natural Superiority of Mules: A Celebration of One of the Most Intelligent, Sure-footed, and Misunderstood Animals in the World. New York, NY: Skyhorse Publishing; 2006.
Dr. Scheurer is a hospitalist and chief quality officer at the Medical University of South Carolina in Charleston. She is physician editor of The Hospitalist. Email her at [email protected].